Advances in assessment indicators of irrigation water use efficiency

CUI Yuan-lai; XIONG Jia

Volume 20 Issue 4

Turn off MathJax

Article Contents

Abstract

References

Advances in Water Science > 2009 > 20(4): 590-598.

CUI Yuan-lai, XIONG Jia. Advances in assessment indicators of irrigation water use efficiency[J]. Advances in Water Science, 2009, 20(4): 590-598.

Citation:

CUI Yuan-lai, XIONG Jia. Advances in assessment indicators of irrigation water use efficiency[J]. Advances in Water Science, 2009, 20(4): 590-598.

Citation:

CUI Yuan-lai, XIONG Jia. Advances in assessment indicators of irrigation water use efficiency[J]. Advances in Water Science, 2009, 20(4): 590-598.

PDF (991 KB)

Advances in assessment indicators of irrigation water use efficiency

State Key Laboratory of Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering Science, Wuhan University, Wuhan 430072, China

More Information

Received Date: June 29, 2008

Graphical Abstract

Abstract

Abstract

The definitions and their utlization about the assessment indicators of the irrigation water use efficiency (IWUE) are reviewed. The disadvantages and their use conditions of the existing IWUE are analyzed. We conclude that no indicators can be used to quantify IWUE in any conditions. Firstly, the connotations of different nomenclature of IWUE are ambiguity, which results in the use interchangeably of various terms regardless of the precise implications of their recommendations. Secondly, some new concepts of assessment framework and indicators are right, but it is difficult to determine the components in the framework, and thus not suitable for the utilization in water management in an irrigation system. Finally, we point out the essentiality of giving the precise implications of the existing IWUEs and their specific use conditions, investigate their relationships and affecting factors, and propose the methodology of evaluating the water saving potiential.
- irrigation water use efficiency,
- irrigation efficiency,
- water productivity,
- assessment indicator,
- water saving potiential

FullText(HTML)

References (49)

References

[1]	MOLDEN D.Accounting for water use and productivity[M].Colombo:IWMI,Sri Lanka,1997:16.
[2]	JENSEN M E.Water conservation and irrigation systems[C]//Proceedings of the ClimatE-Technology Seminar.Colombia:[s.n.],1977:208-250.
[3]	KELLER A A,KELLER J.Effective efficiency:A water use efficiency concept for allocating freshwater resources[R].Winrock International:Water Resources and Irrigation Division,VA,1995:19.
[4]	PERRY C J.The IWMI water resources paradigm-definitions and implications[J].Agricultural Water Management,1999,40:45-50.
[5]	PERRY C J.Efficient irrigation,inefficient communication,flawed recommendations[J].Irrigation and Drainage,2007,56:367-378.
[6]	陈伟,郑连生,聂建中.节水灌溉的水资源评价体系[J].南水北调与水利科技,2005,3(3):32-34.(CHEN Wei,ZHENG Lian-sheng,NIE Jian-zhong.A new water resources assessment system in water-saving irrigation[J].South-to-North Water Transfers and Water Science & Technology,2005,3(3):32-34.(in Chinese))
[7]	MARINUS G B.Standards for irrigation efficiencies of ICID[J].J Irrig and Drain Engrg,ASCE,1979,105(1):37-43.
[8]	WOLTERS W.Influences on the efficiency of irrigation water use[M].The Netherlands:International Institute for Land Reclamation and Improvement (IILRI) Publications,1992:150.
[9]	水利部.农村水利技术术语[S].北京:中国水利水电出版社,2005.(Ministry of Water Resources.Technical terminology for rural water conservancy[S].Beijing:China WaterPower Press,2005.(in Chinese))
[10]	王会肖,刘昌明.作物水分利用效率内涵及研究进展[J].水科学进展,2000,11(1):99-104.(WANG Hui-xiao,LIU Chang-ming.Advances in crop water use efficiency research[J].Advances in Water Science,2000,11(1):99-104.(in Chinese))
[11]	沈荣开,杨路华,王康.关于以水分生产率作为节水灌溉指标的认识[J].中国农村水利水电,2001(5):9-11.(SHEN Rong-kai,YANG Lu-hua,WANG Kang.Recognition of taking water productivity as index of water saving irrigation[J].China Rural Water Resources and Hydropower,2001(5):9-11.(in Chinese))
[12]	蔡守华,张展羽,张德强.修正灌溉水利用效率指标体系的研究[J].水利学报,2004,35(5):111-115.(CAI Shou-hua,ZHANG Zhan-yu,ZHANG DE-qiang.Modified index system for utilization efficiency of irrigation water[J].Journal of Hydraulic Engineering,2004,35(5):111-115.(in Chinese))
[13]	田娟,郭宗楼,姚水萍.灌区灌溉管理质量指标的综合因子分析[J].水科学进展,2005,16(2):284-288.(TIAN Juan,GUO Zong-lou,YAO Shui-ping.Analysis of comprehensive principal factors in irrigation management level index of irrigation area[J].Advances in Water Science,2005,16(2):284-288.(in Chinese))
[14]	王景雷,吴景社,齐学斌,等.节水灌溉评价研究进展[J].水科学进展,2002,13(4):521-525.(WANG Jing-lei,WU Jing-she,QI XuE-bin,et al.Advances in water saving irrigation evaluation[J].Advances in Water Science,2002,13(4):521-525.(in Chinese))
[15]	蔡甲冰,刘钰,雷廷武,等.精量灌溉决策定量指标研究现状与进展[J].水科学进展,2004,15(4):531-537.(CAI Jia-bing,LIU Yu,LEI Ting-wu,et al.Review of indices for precision irrigation decision-making[J].Advances in Water Science,2004,15(4):531-537.(in Chinese))
[16]	HART W E,SKOGERBOE G V,PERI G,et al.Irrigation performance:An evaluation[J].J Irrig and Drain Engrg,ASCE,1979,105 (3):275-288.
[17]	BURT C M,CLEMMENS A J,STRELKOFF T S,et al.Irrigation performance measures:Efficiency and uniformity[J].J Irrig and Drain Engrg,ASCE,1997,123(6):423-442.
[18]	US Interagency Task Force.Irrigation water use and management[R].Washington DC:US Gov Printing Office,USA,1979:143.
[19]	WILLARDSON L S,ALLEN R G,FREDERIKSEN H,et al.Universal fractions and the elimination of irrigation efficiencies[C]//Paper presented at the 13th Technical Conference of the US Committee on Irrigation and Drainage.Denver:Colorado,1994:15.
[20]	KELLER A A,SECKLER DW,KELLER J.Integrated water resource systems:Theory and policy implications[R].Colombo:IWMI,Sri Lanka,1996:14.
[21]	LANKFORD B A.Localising irrigation efficiency[J].Irrigation and Drainage,2006,55:345-362.
[22]	高传昌,张世宝,刘增进.灌溉渠系水利用系数的分析与计算[J].灌溉排水,2001,20(3):50-54.(GAO Chuan-chang,ZHANG Shi-bao,Liu Zeng-jin.Analysis and calculation of conveyance efficiency of an irrigation canal system[J].Irrigation and Drainage,2001,20(3):50-54.(in Chinese))
[23]	汪富贵.大型灌区灌溉水利用系数的分析方法[J].武汉水利电力大学学报,1999,32(6):28-31.(WANG Fu-gui.Analytical method of irrigation efficiency of large-size irrigation district[J].J Wuhan Univ of Hydr & Elec Eng,1999,32(6):28-31.(in Chinese))
[24]	沈小谊,黄永茂,沈逸轩.灌区水资源利用系数研究[J].中国农村水利水电,2003(1):21-24.(SHEN Xiao-yi,HUANG Yong-mao,SHEN Yi-xuan.Research on the water use efficiency in irrigation district[J].China Rural Water Resources and Hydropower,2003(1):21-24.(in Chinese))
[25]	沈逸轩,黄永茂,沈小谊.年灌溉水利用系数的研究[J].中国农村水利水电,2005(7):7-8.(SHEN Yi-xuan,HUANG Yong-mao,SHEN Xiao-yi.Research on annual irrigation water use efficiency[J].China Rural Water Resources and Hydropower,2005(7):7-8.(in Chinese))
[26]	谢柳青,李桂元,余健来.南方灌区灌溉水利用系数确定方法研究[J].武汉大学学报,2001,34(2):17-19.(XIE Liu-qing,LI Gui-yuan,YU Jian-lai.Research on method of determining irrigation water efficiency of irrigation districts in China's southern region[J].Engineering Journal of Wuhan University,2001,34(2):17-19.(in Chinese))
[27]	中国灌溉排水发展中心.全国现状灌溉水利用系数测算分析报告[R].北京:中国灌溉排水发展中心,2007:68.(China Centre for Irrigation and Drainage Development.Research report on measurement of irrigation water use efficiency of China[R].Beijing:China Centre for Irrigation and Drainage Development,2007:68.(in Chinese))
[28]	沈荣开,张瑜芳,杨金忠.内蒙河套引黄灌区节水改造中推行井渠结合的几个问题[J].中国农村水利水电,2001(2):16-19.(SHEN Rong-kai,ZHANG Yu-fang,YANG Jin-zhong.Issues of joint utilization of surface and ground water in the reconstrution and rehabilitation of Hetao irrigation district,Inner Mongolia,China[J].China Rural Water Resources and Hydropower,2001(2):16-19.(in Chinese))
[29]	李远华,董斌,崔远来.尺度效应及其节水灌溉策略[J].世界科技研究与发展,2005,27(6):31-35.(LI Yuan-hua,DONG Bin,CUI Yuan-lai.Scale effect and strategy for water saving irrigation[J].World Sci-Tech R&D,2005,27(6):31-35.(in Chinese))
[30]	董斌,崔远来,李远华.水稻灌区节水灌溉的尺度效应[J].水科学进展,2005,16(6):833-839.(DONG Bin,CUI Yuan-lai,LI Yuan-hua.Scale effect of water saving in ricE-based irrigation system[J].Advances in Water Science,2005,16(6):833-839.(in Chinese))
[31]	崔远来,董斌,李远华,等.农业节水灌溉评价指标与尺度问题.农业工程学报,2007,23(7):1-7.(CUI Yuan-lai,DONG Bin,LI Yuan-hua,et al.Assessment indicators and scales of water saving in agricultural irrigation[J].Transactions of the CSAE,2007,23(7):1-7.(in Chinese))
[32]	代俊峰,崔远来.灌溉水文学及其研究进展[J].水科学进展,2008,19(2):294-300.(DAI Jun-feng,CUI Yuan-lai.Progress in study of the irrigation hydrology[J].Advances in Water Science,2008,19(2):294-300.(in Chinese))
[33]	GUERRA L C,BHUIYAN S I,TUONG T P,et al.Producing more rice with less water from irrigated systems[R].Colombo:IWMI,Sri Lanka,1998:24.
[34]	ZOEBL D.Is water productivity a useful concept in agricultural water management[J].Agricultural Water Management,2006,84:265-273.
[35]	MOLDEN D,SAKTHIVADIVEL R,CHRISTOPHER J,et al.Indicators for comparing performance of irrigated agricultural systems[R].Colombo:IWMI,Sri Lanka,1998:29.
[36]	KLOEZEN W H,GARCES R C.Assessing irrigation performance with comparative indicators:The case of the Alto Bio Lerma irrigation district,Mexico[R].Colombo:IWMI,Sri Lanka,1998,39.
[37]	MCCARTNEY M P,LANKFORD B A,MAHOO H.Agricultural water management in a water stressed catchment:Lessons from the RIPARWIN Project[R].Colombo:IWMI,Sri Lanka,2007:46.
[38]	BASTIAANSSEN W G M,MOLDEN D,THIRUVENGADACHARI S,et al.Remote sensing and hydrologic models for performance assessment in Sirsa Irrigation Circle,India[R].Colombo:IWMI,Sri Lanka,1999:29.
[39]	DROOGERS P,GEOFF K.Estimating productivity of water at different spatial scales using simulation modeling[R].Colombo:IWMI,Sri Lanka,2001:16.
[40]	BOUMAN B A M,KROPFF M J,WOPPEREIS M C S,et al.ORYZA 2000:Modeling lowland rice[M].Los Baos:International Rice Research Institute and Wageningen University and Research Centre,2001:235.
[41]	DAM V J C,HUYGEN J,WESSELING J G,et al.User's guide of SWAP Version 2.0,simulation of water flow,solute transport and plant growth in the Soil-Water-AtmospherE-Plant environment[M].Wageningen:Wageningen Agricultural Unilersity,1997.
[42]	胡远安,程声通,贾海峰.非点源模型中的水文模拟:以SWAT模型在芦溪小流域的应用为例[J].环境科学研究,2003,16(5):29-36.(Hu Yuan-an,CHENG Sheng-tong,JIA Hai-feng.Hydrologic simulation in NPS models:Application of SWAT in Luxi watershed[J].Research of Environmental Science.2003,16(5):29-32.(in Chinese))
[43]	代俊峰.基于分布式水文模型的灌区水管理研究[D].武汉:武汉大学,2007:142.(DAI Jun-feng.Water management in irrigated area based on distributed hydrological model[D].Wuhan:Wuhan University,2007:142.(in Chinese))
[44]	SOPHOCLEOUS M,PERKINS P P.Methodology and application of combined watershed and ground-water models in Kansas[J].Journal of Hydrology,2000,236(3/4):185-201.
[45]	ELHASSAN A M,GOTO A,MIZUTANI M.Effect of conjunctive use of water for paddy field irrigation on groundwater budget in an alluvial fan[C]//HUANG Guan-hua,Luis S P.Land and Water Management:Decision Tools and Practices.Beijing:China Agriculture Press,2004:20-28.
[46]	SECKLER D.The new era of water resources management:From ‘dry' to ‘wet' water savings[R].Colombo:IWMI,Sri Lanka,1996:17.
[47]	茆智.节水潜力分析要考虑尺度效应[J].中国水利,2005(15):14-15.(MAO Zhi.Scaling effect should be considered in water saving potential analysis[J].China Water Resources,2005(15):14-15.(in Chinese))
[48]	裴源生,张金萍,赵勇.宁夏灌区节水潜力的研究[J].水利学报,2007,38(2):239-248.(PEI Yuan-sheng,ZHANG Jin-ping,ZHAO Yong.Water saving potential in irrigation area of Ningxia autonomous region[J].Journal of Hydraulic Engineering,2007,38(2):239-248.(in Chinese))
[49]	沈振荣,汪林,于福亮,等.节水新概念:真实节水的研究与应用[M].北京:中国水利电力出版社,2000:245.(SHEN Zhen-rong,WANG Lin,YU Hu-liang,et al.New concepts of water saving-study and application of real water saving[M].Beijing:China WaterPower Press,2000:245.(in Chinese))

Cited By

Get Citation

PDF

XML

Article Metrics

Article views (204) PDF downloads (1450)

Advances in assessment indicators of irrigation water use efficiency

Abstract

References

Catalog

Article Metrics

Related

Advances in assessment indicators of irrigation water use efficiency

Abstract

References

Catalog

Article Metrics

Related

Export File

Citation

Format

Content